Designing a county service that adapts to each municipality and works as a single system

Consell Comarcal del Baix Empordà

Feasibility study and tender specifications for the new county-wide waste collection service

Designing a county service that adapts to each municipality and works as a single system

The challenge

Baix Empordà was defining a new county-wide waste collection service in an especially varied territory: municipalities of very different sizes, urban centres and scattered dwellings, high seasonality, different collection models already in place, and very diverse urban layouts.

The baseline analysis also showed significant room for improvement. Total waste generation had grown 7.5% since 2012, and per-capita generation stood in 2022 at 821.27 kg/inhabitant/year — well above the Catalan average, largely due to tourism and second homes. Source separation stood at 52%, and comparative analysis showed very significant differences between municipalities with open containers and those with door-to-door collection.

The challenge, then, wasn’t simply replacing a service.

The challenge was building a county-wide system able to increase efficiency, improve source separation, and prepare the territory for data- and participation-based management, without losing the ability to adapt to each municipality’s characteristics.

Project development

The project was structured in four phases:

  1. Diagnosis and territorial analysis. Analysis of current generation and results, existing collection systems, and the main urban, territorial and activity-related constraints across the municipalities.
  2. Defining the model. Identifying the most suitable system for each municipality, defining contribution systems, schedules, frequencies and sizing criteria, and grouping services to optimise routes.
  3. Technology and service management. Integrating identification, traceability, access control and data management systems to enable participation tracking and prepare the service for future behaviour-based taxation.
  4. Drafting and structuring the tender. Translating the defined model into technical and administrative specifications, the financial report, and the structure needed to tender and roll out the new county service.

Results

The result was a new contract for the municipalities that had delegated the service, with an initial 10-year term, a transition phase of up to six months, and a structure ready for the progressive rollout of the new collection models.

Conclusions

The Baix Empordà project shows that an efficient county service needs a common architecture able to adapt to different territorial realities.

The main goal was to move from a fragmented reality to a county-wide system with shared criteria, while still allowing for municipal adaptation.

The key was working at both scales at once: individualising the model where necessary, and pooling resources where that could generate efficiency.

Technology was brought in as infrastructure for the service itself, making it possible to identify contributions, measure participation, and generate information to track and evolve the model.

The contract itself includes source-separation and quality targets, along with monitoring mechanisms and corrective actions, turning the tender into a results-oriented tool rather than just a description of resources.

This wasn’t about choosing between county-wide efficiency and territorial adaptation. It was about designing the service so both were possible.

Lessons learned

A county service isn’t a uniform service. Joint management doesn’t mean applying the same model to every municipality. Efficiency comes from sharing resources, technology and criteria without losing territorial adaptation.

Territory is part of sizing. Urban form, how spread out housing is, economic activity and seasonality all directly shape routes, frequencies and contribution systems.

Technology has to be designed together with the service. Identification and traceability make sense when they’re built into day-to-day operations and turn every contribution into useful information for managing and improving the service.

Specifications can shape how a service behaves. Setting targets for source separation, participation and quality, and linking them to monitoring systems and corrective actions, turns a resource-based contract into a results-oriented one.

Planning has to allow for evolution. The service was designed with a transition phase and room to bring in improvements and adapt provisions to the territory’s needs over the life of the contract.

Designing a county service means finding the balance between scale, territory and the capacity to evolve.